Ingredients

How to make it

  • Girl Scout Samoa Cookies... I don't know if you have ever wanted to bake something so bad because of a picture you saw, because it looked so, so gooood to you. Well, I first saw this recipe on tastespotting a few months ago. It was featured by Onceuponaplate. She made the homemade Girl Scout Samoa Cookies that caught my eye.... an outstanding job with the presentation. I have since then wanted to make them. They looked sooo goood that I had to try making them once at least. She gave credit to BakingBites for the recipe. So, I in turn, thank both of them for the recipe! I suggest that you read the original recipe found on either of their blogs. I have a few tips that will make the cookies not so labor intensive and to help with the way they come out. I know I will still try to improve on the aesthetics of my cookies so that they too will look somewhat professional.
  • I like to make recipes from scratch as close as I can...this recipe does involve using store bought caramels. I think I will be in search of homemade caramels that I would like to use next time. For now, I have opted to follow the recipe almost to the tee:)! Oh, how were the cookies?!....they were just too good....excellent!!! I had to put them in the freezer(in the back somewhere), so that we wouldn't eat more than our share! It was a lot of fun making these cookies.
  • Here are the tips:
  • ~I made the cookie dough a day in advance(you can also put in fridge for a few hours) to solidify the butter which eliminates the cookie from spreading out when baked.
  • ~Shaped the dough in a round log...about 2 inch in diameter...I didn't want to mess around with rolling the dough between parchment paper and having it stick... This was mess free!!!
  • ~The thickness of the cookie matters!!...don't make them too thin or they will break on you...rather err on a thicker cookie.
  • ~Don't overbake/underbake the cookies...just until it is lightly golden around the edges.
  • ~Used the end of decorating piping tips to form the inside hole...the hole will somewhat shrink as it bakes...I used the decorating piping tip to reform the hole after the cookies had cooled....you don't have to do that.
  • ~I think the best way to melt the chocolate is in a double boiler...this keeps the chocolate warm and fluid like and therefore easier to dip the cookies.
  • ~The caramel mixture needs to be kept warm as well...if it cools too much it will clump on you and not stick to the cookies.
  • ~ I did not use the milk at all and omitted the salt
  • ~You can toast the coconut the day before.
  • ~This recipe will come together much faster if you have an extra pair of hands.

Reviews & Comments 1

Add a Link?

Post a link to another recipe or group by pasting the url into the box where you want it to show up. We'll do the rest.

Post Message or cancel
  • elgourmand 13 years ago
    I'm gonna love these cookies but the sad news is that there are no Girl Scouts in Samoa. RJ
    Was this review helpful? Yes Flag

Maybe List
Hang onto this recipe

while I look at others.

Holding 0 recipes