Stovetop Colonial Peanut Butter Fudge Squares Recipe

Tag Filters

---

• quick 4
• easy 14
• cheap 1
• View More ↓

Ingredient Filters

---

• corn syrup 2
• light corn syrup 2
• corn 1
• vegetables 1
• View More ↓

• peanut butter 25
• butter 15
• milk 12
• creamy peanut butter 4
• sweetened condensed milk 4
• evaporated milk 3
• peanut butter chips 3
• chunky peanut butter 2
• unsalted butter 2
• crunchy peanut butter 1
• margarine 1
• skim milk powder 1
• smooth peanut butter 1
• whole milk 1
• View More ↓

• cocoa 4
• chocolate chips 2
• dark chocolate chips 1
• milk chocolate chips 1
• semisweet chocolate morsels 1
• sweet chocolate 1
• View More ↓

• peanut 18
• walnuts 1
• View More ↓

• sugar 17
• marshmallows 6
• brown sugar 3
• marshmallow cream 3
• flour 2
• coconut 2
• confectioners' sugar 2
• honey 2
• shortening 1
• icing sugar 1
• tea 1
• marshmallow creme 1
• rice krispies 1
• toast 1
• orange 1
• boiling water 1
• powdered sugar 1
• light brown sugar 1
• miniature marshmallows 1
• extract 1
• graham cracker crumbs 1
• crisp rice cereal 1
• eggs 1
• dark brown sugar 1
• baking soda 1
• fudge sauce 1
• butterscotch chips 1
• graham crackers 1
• cracker crumbs 1
• vegetable shortening 1
• View More ↓

• vanilla 16
• cider vinegar 1
• sesame seeds 1
• vinegar 1
• View More ↓

Cook Time Filters

---

• under 5 mins 13
• under 15 mins 21