Never Fail Macaroni Salad I Made It

Never Fail Macaroni Salad

browneyegirl 9 years ago
I don't know on how many of you had gone to Marriage's page.That person has alot of great recipes.When I came across this recipe on Never Fail Macaroni Salad that I thought that it sounded pretty good.It all most reminds me of store bought Macaroni Salad.Last night that I had all ready had the eggs, celery done.I thought to myself stead of using green onions that I used regular onions.I had that part done as well.All I had to do is just the carrots and green pepper to do along with the macaroni.I "DIDN'T" use the hole pound of the pasta noodles though.I know it said colored spiriral pasta.I used elbow macaroni.
This is the way I done mine on this salad.1 3/4 cups elbow macaroni, 6 eggs, 2 carrots, 1 green pepper, 1 onion, 2 celery's, 1 envelope of the Good Season's Italian salad dressing (The photo that you see below is what I used) & I know it says mayonnaise but I used Miracle Whip instead.As I mixed everything up into a bigger bowl & I tasted it & it's not bad at all.As you see that I added the salad into a bowl (Yes it's a butter bowl) and I had a little bit left that I'll have Chris take to his mom (That's if he does that is).

This would be great for the holidays and even cook outs as well.
Flag
pointsevenout 9 years ago said:

Yay! Another Miracle Whip lover. :)

Flag
browneyegirl 9 years ago said:

That's me.I "LOVE" Miracle Whip.I was brought up on it.I know my mom likes the mayo.I sure don't.

Flag
mommyluvs2cook 9 years ago said:

I think y'all may be the only 2 in here that like that stuff :P Did you use the whole quart of it? Seems like A LOT!!

Flag
browneyegirl 9 years ago said:

Mommyluvs2cook, LOL.Maybe we might be the only ones who might like this but never know who else might like it.OMG! I think that Chris's mom & his family may like it as well.On the miracle whip I only took 3 spoons of it and it turned out perfect.When I say 3 spoons of it I meant the metal spoon.I think that the hole quart of it would be too much I think.Wouldn't you think so Pointsevenout?

Flag
mommyluvs2cook 9 years ago said:

Are you talking about the spoons you would eat soup with, or the big metal spoons you may stir a soup pot with? Lol, I just saw this is the same recipe Points made last week and I commented the same comment about all the mayo/whip in that one too... Okay I have Mommy brain...lol!!

Flag
browneyegirl 9 years ago said:

Yes I'm talking about the one that you eat soup with.

Flag
NPMarie 9 years ago said:

Pointsevenout's review :-)
Never Fail Macaroni Salad

Flag
browneyegirl 9 years ago said:

NPMarie, yeah I seen his as well.

Flag
lovebreezy 9 years ago said:

BEG just for your information, we in the IMI group are trying to cut down on the number of threads we have here. When we want to review a recipe we first look to see if that particular recipe already has a review thread for it. If so, we add our review onto that thread rather than starting a new one.
It's nothing to fret over, it's not a rule and we all miss one on occasion. I just wanted to inform you in case you didn't know.
The way we check for an existing thread is by going to the Beta Reviews List 12 3 13 and look for it there.
Sorry to say, that list is not complete but I'm working on that.

Flag
browneyegirl 9 years ago said:

Okay

Flag
mommyluvs2cook 9 years ago said:

Or if you can't find it in the Beta list just check the comments on the recipe to make sure someone didn't leave a link back here of them making it :)

Flag
gourmetana 9 years ago said:

What is miracle whip? A mayo substitute?

Flag
browneyegirl 9 years ago said:

Mommyluvs2cook, Okay.
Gourmetana, I posted a photo of the Miracle Whip up above.I don't know how to explain it.

Flag
lovebreezy 9 years ago said:

Yes Ana, Miracle Whip is a mayo sub. It is sweeter than mayo and does not have the lemon that mayo does. Always a big debate in the US if you're a Mayo or Miracle Whip person. Just like the question--Coke or Pepsi.

Flag
browneyegirl 9 years ago said:

Lovebreezy, thank you for explaing it.The reason why I say that is because I "DON'T" use mayo.All I use is the Miracle Whip.

Flag