Scalloped OystersFrom krumkake 5 years ago
- 1 pound fresh shucked oysters (canned are not nearly as good for this recipe), drained and juice reserved (if oysters are large, cut them in half) shopping list
- half-and-half or heavy cream (no reduced fat in this!) shopping list
- ½ cup butter, melted shopping list
- ½ teaspoon worcestershire sauce shopping list
- ¼ teaspoon salt shopping list
- dash of pepper shopping list
- 2½ cups (or more, as needed) coarsely crushed saltine crackers, not finely crushed shopping list
- 2 tablespoons cold butter shopping list
How to make it
- VERY generously butter a glass casserole or 7x11 glass baking dish (using a glass dish is important, as it helps gives the baked dish a nice crusty bottom and edges, rather than just the top).
- Drain oyster liquid into a measuring cup and add cream or half-and-half to make 1 cup of liquid.
- Melt ½ cup butter in a separate measuring cup (in the microwave) and stir in Worcestershire, salt and pepper.
- Place a layer of cracker crumbs over bottom of buttered baking dish, then a layer of ½ of the oysters; pour ½ of the melted butter mixture over the oysters (BE SURE TO STIR BEFORE POURING because the seasonings all settle to the bottom of the cup!) .
- Repeat the layers one more time, reserving some of the cracker crumbs for the topping.
- After putting on the final layer of cracker crumbs over the top, dot the top with slivers of the 2 tablespoons cold butter.
- Just before putting casserole in the oven, pour oyster/milk mixture over top of casserole (do not do this ahead of time, or the crackers will absorb too much liquid and the end result will be soggy).
- Bake uncovered at 350 degrees for 35 to 45 minutes, until top is lightly browned and crunchy.
- NOTE: I have never done this before, since I make this for family at the holidays (and they wouldn't like me messing with the family tradition, ya know!), but someone once suggested that they thought this would be good with some hot sauce added to the cream...you decide!
People Who Like This Dish 9
The Cookkrumkake Chicago Suburbs, IL
The Rating4 people
This has been one of my holiday dishes since my husband & I got married. He is the one who told me what was in it & I found it in a Grange book. Funny thing he will not eat any fish or seafood, yet he loves this dish. Now my family loves it & my sist...morecherihannah in Shickshinny loved it
I grew up eating scalloped oysters, fried oysters, oysters..... I will try yours, it sounds like my kinda recipe.helewes in Newton loved it
This was very, very, tasty. I sat aside a whole day to cook last weekend and made this long with some other great recipes. This was a bit like doing an edible art project :) My entire family enjoyed it.helewes in Newton loved it