How to make it

  • Cookie Dough

  • Cream butter and sugar. Add eggs, vanilla, and peanut butter. In a separate bowl mix flours & baking powder. Slowly add dry ingredients to wet, mixing well to incorporate. Wrap in plastic and refrigerate for at least 3 hours.
  • Preheat oven to 375F. Line baking sheet with parchment paper. Divide cookie dough into 20 equal portions. (You may have to let it sit out for a few minutes until it's easier to work with.) Roll each section into a ball. Place ball on baking sheet and flatten with your palm. Then use a fork to flatten a bit more. The cookies will not spread much but do leave a bit of room between them. Bake for 10 minutes. Move to rack to cool.
  • Filling

  • Combine all ingredients. Mix well. Once cookies are cooled, spread filling on bottom of one cookie & top with another. Repeat until you have 10 sandwiches.
  • Store in an airtight container.

Reviews & Comments 10

Add a Link?

Post a link to another recipe or group by pasting the url into the box where you want it to show up. We'll do the rest.

Post Message or cancel
  • jett2whit 1 year ago
    Oh yeahhhhh! YUMMY!!!
    Was this review helpful? Yes Flag
  • Cosmicmother 1 year ago
    Featured recipe: 20/01/2016! :)
    These look amazing, love me some peanut butter!
    Was this review helpful? Yes Flag
  • NPMarie 6 years ago
    LOVE Nutter Butters...I can't believe I missed this..will try soon :)
    Was this review helpful? Yes Flag
  • jkirk 6 years ago
    Nutter Butters are great cookies, and these sound excellent!
    Was this review helpful? Yes Flag
  • keni 6 years ago
    ummm.... yummm....peanut butter! (that's twice today I've saved a peanut butter recipe... someone trying to tell me something?? :)
    Was this review helpful? Yes Flag
  • doreenfish 6 years ago
    Its a save for me...thank you!!
    Was this review helpful? Yes Flag
  • otterpond 6 years ago
    Decadent! Alternative on the filling would be to mix the cream cheese with some concord grape jam. Just a thought I had :)
    Was this review helpful? Yes Flag
  • pleclare 6 years ago
    These look and sound fantastic...
    Was this review helpful? Yes Flag
  • sparow64 6 years ago
    Dahlia, these look awesome! Nutter Butters are one of my faves!! Can't wait to try these!
    Was this review helpful? Yes Flag
  • hunnee 6 years ago
    very delicious, thanks for posting this tasty recipe
    Was this review helpful? Yes Flag

Maybe List
Hang onto this recipe

while I look at others.

Holding 0 recipes