Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Fudge Recipe

Tag Filters

---

• quick 6
• easy 30
• cheap 3
• unique 1
• View More ↓

Cuisine Filters

---

• nothing specific 17
• southern 1

Ingredient Filters

---

• light corn syrup 4
• vegetables 4
• corn syrup 3
• white corn syrup 2
• corn 1
• cornstarch 1
• View More ↓

• peanut butter 61
• butter 40
• milk 28
• evaporated milk 10
• creamy peanut butter 9
• margarine 9
• sweetened condensed milk 9
• peanut butter chips 7
• chunky peanut butter 6
• unsalted butter 6
• crunchy peanut butter 2
• smooth peanut butter 2
• whipping cream 2
• whole milk 2
• buttermilk 1
• condensed milk 1
• heavy whipping cream 1
• light butter 1
• low-fat milk 1
• peanut butter cups 1
• sour cream 1
• whipped cream 1
• View More ↓

• cocoa 11
• unsweetened chocolate 5
• chocolate 4
• semi-sweet chocolate chips 4
• chocolate chips 3
• semisweet chocolate 3
• chocolate fudge topping 2
• sweet chocolate 2
• unsweetened cocoa 2
• baking chocolate 1
• bittersweet chocolate 1
• chocolate cookie crumbs 1
• chocolate frosting 1
• chocolate syrup 1
• dark chocolate 1
• dark chocolate chips 1
• dark cocoa 1
• semisweet chocolate morsels 1
• unsweetened cocoa powder 1
• View More ↓

• peanut 42
• walnuts 3
• black walnuts 1
• View More ↓

• sugar 49
• eggs 13
• powdered sugar 11
• marshmallows 10
• flour 9
• brown sugar 8
• confectioners' sugar 6
• marshmallow creme 5
• baking powder 5
• pecans 5
• all-purpose flour 5
• marshmallow cream 4
• baking soda 4
• coconut 3
• apple 3
• boiling water 3
• cream cheese 3
• cake 3
• extract 3
• View More ↓

• vanilla 55
• vegetable oil 4
• View More ↓

Cook Method Filters

---

• stovetop 29
• bake 17
• boil 13
• microwave 13
• freeze-chill 5
• quick 4
• slow-cook 2

Cook Time Filters

---

• under 5 mins 36
• under 15 mins 53